Coyle`s Homemade Ice Cream in Bay Shore

Just trust me. Go there. Get anything. Be happy.

I love their Ice Cream Cakes. 👍

If I could eat all the flavors in my one and probably only trip (I'm visiting the area, not because it's bad), I would.

Nice old time iced cream shop with a counter and booths. Plenty of flavor and toppings choices, friendly staff. Delicious

Very genuine, great customer service, made me feel like a kid again and was very welcoming. The ice cream is old fashioned and they always have great specials. I would recommend to anyone that wants to treat themselves.

Was really good until about 5 mins after I finished my throat felt very sticky

We ordered a Quart of ice cream online and requested that the 4 flavors be separated possibly into different containers. Our request was not met. Doesn't seem like it would be that hard, so now we are stuck with 4 flavors blended into one giant mush. Simply separating the flavors for us could have made it 100x better.

I love this place! Homemade ice cream. Many amazing flavors to choose from. They have soft served ice cream as well. There are weekly specials for different days of the week like; discounted root beer floats, banana splits, sundaes, I'm not sure which days are which but you can call ahead or there's a sign up when you go. Service was lovely. They let you mix and match flavors They also sell homemade ice cream cakes and ice cream sandwiches which I haven't gotten to try yet but they look amazing.

Quality ice cream and a kept up old school decor.

Never had a problem before but when I went in today to get a small waffle cone ice cream I was charged $7.50. I got home and called the owner who argued with me. I then pointed out that Hershey charges $4.50 for a small waffle cone. He said the worker may have misunderstood what I asked for but she didn’t, it was very clear to her. Finally he told me he would refund the difference between what I was charged and the correct price of $5.50 for a small cone. Be very careful if you go into this place and verify the price against what is posted on the wall.

Definitely, definitely definitely definitely, definitely going to try this place again. My daughter Google searched and ice cream place right after dinner in a nearby area and we went to this place for the first time. They had so many flavors. It looked amazing. Of course I tried the Ferrero Rocher ice cream, which I never knew even existed. It was so good I think I'm going to go right after work today because it's making me hungry just writing this review. Definitely recommend it for anybody who even kind of likes ice cream indefinitely to anybody who loves ice cream. 🍨🍦🍨 They also have cakes and ice cream sandwiches, as well as soft serve. Definitely a Must Try!

This place is fabulous. It doesn't look like much but the ice cream is out of this world! My wife and I stopped over and as I ate the ice cream I just couldn't stop. They have several exotic flavors and everything is fresh 😋. They have shakes, sundaes, floats, ice cream cake, cones, waffles, etc. Definitely heaven on earth.

Ice cream is ready rich and flavorful it's decadent. The specialty Sunday are just an absolute delight be sure you grab some.

I had the rum and raisin and it was amazing. I was sceptical at first because I thought there would be lack of choice however I was pleasantly surprised to see the wide selection of flavors. I am definitely going again. The ice cream is so rich and flavorful.

What better way to celebrate your birthday (or any day) then with an awesome sundae specialty at Coyles! Made before your eyes, vast and delicious!! Wow!

I went to go pick up a cake and it’s not the first time we have gone there. there was a gentleman in front of us and the worker gladly grabbed his cake. when I was next in line (and no one was behind me to say it was busy) the worker asked how he can help I stated I came to pick up a cake as well and the worker ASKED ME to go get it. don’t think that was right. Especially with what’s going on, me touching another persons cake box is not the smartest thing. It was not busy, not sure why I received different treatment. I called the shop to speak with the manager and he didn’t seem to care. terrible customer service.

The Mint Oreo ice cream I had was fantastic - creamy, actually had a good amount of Oreos in it, and the price was fair. Nice staff and served quickly. Would happily come back!